Contemplating Surgery For Plantar Fasciitis And Other Foot Issues

by Linda

I have been through it all for 18 months with no relief from Plantar Fasciitis or so we thought until the doctors finally did a bone scan and MRI. The bone scan lit up like a Christmas tree.

Two orthopedic physicians were amazed with what they saw in my foot. I have five conditions at one time.

1. Osteochondral lesion medial talar dome w/ surrounding bone marrow edema.

2. Mild bone marrow edema lateral talus, lateral calcancus and the cuboid.

3. Posterior tibial tendinosis.

4. Posterior planter faciitis.

5. Chronic anterior talofibular ligament tear.

I have surgery scheduled in a couple of weeks. However, I am concerned. He wants to do five procedures and the only one that concerns me is the endoscopic planter fascia release. He mentioned doing an 80% release.

Is is possible that by correcting with the other four procedures that the Plantar Fasciitis would get better? I am really reluctant to have the PF cut, especially 80%.



Joshua Answers:

Hello Linda.

Yikes. That's a lot going on in your foot.

Makes me wonder why all that is going on in the first place.

To answer your specific question, I can't imagine that cutting through 80% of the structural connective tissue that supports and holds together the bottom of your foot is going to reverse any of the factors that caused all this in the first place.

Maybe, but.....personally I wouldn't do it.

I'm not a doctor, I can't (legally) say whether it will help or not, and really, I don't know.

The thing is, your doctors don't really know either.

It could be that this is happening because you don't have -enough- support in the foot, or at least, some parts aren't doing their job and other parts have to pick up the slack and work harder than they are happy to work.

Maybe you have plantar fasciitis pain from the plantar fascia having to shoulder too much of the load, for instance, because when the posterior tibialias isn't doing it's job correctly it lets the foot arch fall flat, which then overstretches the plantar fascia.

My questions to the doctor(s) would be "What is causing all this in the first place?"

If they have a good answer, I'd be more inclined to believe them if they say surgery can fix it.

Doctors are on the 'surgery to get rid of symptoms' side of things, as opposed to the 'fix the original, actual problem' side of things.

What do they say your chances of recovrey are?

Bone Marrow Edema usually accompanies breaks and fractures in bone. No surprise that you have BME as part of this dynamic. There's a lot of force being improperly applied to the foot, it looks like, and the same forces that are hurting your bones can be ripping your ligaments.

Questions for you:

1. Just one foot, correct?

2. Do you have any osteopenia with the bone marrow edema?

3. What do your daily activities on your feet look like, that may be a clue towards the cause? I'm curious if you are sedentary and just falling apart, or if you are on your feet a lot and pounding them into pieces.

4. Overweight?

5. Overall health?

6. Any other bone problems, Tendonitis issues, or pain issues?

7. Did this suddenly start 18 months ago, or has it been slowly coming on over time. Meaning, did pain show up suddenly, or sneak up on you and gradually get worse and worse.

So I don't know if that answered your question or not. Unfortunately, there is no cut and dry, 100% correct answer out there.

But I think your instinct is correct.

Please reply using the comment link below. Do not submit a new submission to answer/reply, it's too hard for me to find where it's supposed to go.

And, comments have a 3,000 character limit so you may have to comment twice.

Joshua Tucker, B.A., C.M.T.
The Tendonitis Expert

Subscribe to The Tendonitis Expert Newsletter Today!

For TIPS, TRICKS, and up-to-date Tendonitis information you need!




Don't worry -- your e-mail address is totally secure.

I promise to use it only to send you The Tendonitis Expert Newsletter.

Comments for Contemplating Surgery For Plantar Fasciitis And Other Foot Issues

Average Rating starstarstarstarstar

Click here to add your own comments

Aug 06, 2010
80% cutting of tendons on heel and arch
by: Diann A.

When they did my surgery, they cut those tendons on mh left foot, that was in 1992, first few years was fine, then after seven or eight years I started having so much more pain than I ever had, I have no support in that arch and ankle, worst thing I have ever done. Hope there is an alternate surgery that could correct this, if anyone knows, please post your knowledge of it. Thanks, Diann

Sep 29, 2009
PART 2 - More Information - Contemplating Surgery For Plantar Fasciitis And Other Foot Issues
by: Linda

Many years ago I had a bad sprain. At the time, I thought I broke my foot, but it didn't show up on the x-ray. I believe this is part of what is happening. I was a very athletic individual up until my mid 40's. I played softball and ran 5 and 10 K's.

Meaniepause has caused a weight gain that I am having trouble getting off. I weigh about 170. My exercise is very limited due to the pain in my foot.

I work as a high school educator. On and off my feet at all times. My entire career has been on concrete floors. I have always worn good shoes.

I'm thinking that if I have the tendons and ligaments repaired, it may resolve the problem with the PF. So, I think I'm going to have the four procedures done, but hold off on cutting the PF. I've already read about some natural remedies that could help the PF. One being dehydration. So, I've started drinking more H20.

I've thought about purchasing the dvd, but it's a bit costly for me at this time.

Thanks for your thoughts,



Joshua Comments:

Water is indeed a factor. Something like 70% of the US operates in a state of chronic dehydration.

The more dehydrated we are, the less well our body works.

I wonder if that years ago injury ripped some ligament a little bit. It would hurt a lot, not show up an xray, and set you up for a slow but significant Pain Causing Dynamic.

Please let me know how things progress/turn out. And if I can answer any questions along the way, please ask.

Click here to add your own comments

Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How? Simply click here to return to Plantar Fasciitis Surgery Stories.