For the record, I'm a big thumbs down to Tendonitis Surgery in the vast majority of cases.
Primarily because while the tendon -may- have scar tissue build up, and likely is in fact irritated and inflamed, surgery on that spot doesn't address the CAUSE of the scar tissue and inflammation.
Said another way, where the surgeon performs surgery is where pain and problem ENDS UP, but is not where that painful Tendonitis dynamic BEGINS.
Many people get good results from surgery for their particular kind of Tendonitis.
Then again, many people tell me they are pleased with their surgery, even as they describe to me all their remaining symptoms and state that they're still recovering from the surgery 6 months later.
And then there's the people who were actually damaged by their surgery and have WORSE symptoms years later.
Here's the thing: Surgery is done on ONE SPOT. But Tendonitis is due the the ecology of the entire structure.
See: What Is Tendonitis?
If you don't deal with ALL the factors that make up a Tendonitis problem, then it's unlikely that your symptoms are going to go away for very long, if at all. Surgery makes the Process of Inflammation worse, not better.
Surgery won't help in those cases, because obviously surgery doesn't deal with the nutritional deficiency.
What if you have tendon pain because your muscles and connective tissue are too tight? And then what if your surgeon does a tendon release surgery?
The muscles and connective tissue will still be tight, and will get EVEN TIGHTER as your nervous system responds to the injury the Tendonitis surgery causes. And your tendon, which -was- healthy, is now damaged. (Which, ironically, causes Tendonitis.)
There Are Two Types Of Tendonitis, with damage and without.
If there's no damage to the tendon, surgery will only injure it, not help it. And if a tendon is painful, but there's no damage, why do surgery?
Doctors should know that you can have pain without any physical damage, yet they do surgery anyway.
After you do everything your doctor tells you to do, and the usual treatments 'fail', then surgery is next on the list.
But the treatments didn't fail. Rest, Anti-inflammatory drugs like Ibuprofen, Wrist splints and braces, etc, are the WRONG tools for the job, so they never had much of a chance of helping in the first place.
Your doctor failed to help you, and is now saying the surgery is necessary. He was wrong on all the other prescriptions, why would he be correct about this one?
There are MANY good reasons to Quiz Your Doctor about Tendonitis surgery.
Safe is a relative term.
Surgery causes injury, period. The question is, is the benefit worth the risk?
The fact is, it's a crap shoot. If it works, GREAT! But if it doesn't, you usually end up worse off than you were before.
And when you look at Carpal Tunnel Surgery Statistics you'll notice that the definition of 'successful surgery' means 'reduced pain', not 'it's fixed'.
Like I often say, wouldn't you feel stupid if you went in for, say, Carpal Tunnel Surgery, the surgeon accidentally nicked your nerve, you now have permanent nerve damage, and -then- you find out that that original numbness and tingling was actually coming from up at your neck/shoulder/chest and NOT from your wrist?
Or if you just had Vitamin B6 deficiency, or TIGHT muscles in your forearm that could easily be loosened?
I'd feel dumb if that happened to me.
Tendonitis Surgery can be safe, but it can also set you up for a variety of negative experiences, like infection, nerve damage, increased pain levels, irritation of the original Pain Causing Dynamic, etc.
Should you get Tendonitis Surgery?
It's really up to you.
Your body, your choice.
And it depends on the scenario. If an elderly person's hip joint is causing severe pain and there is degradation of/damage to/deterioration of the joint, then a hip joint surgery may be a wise thing.
But if you just have Hip Tendonitis? Not so much.
But if a 30 year old office worker has carpal tunnel syndrome symptoms....then one could argue that surgery is very unwise (since CTS is pretty simple to fix non-surgically, with no risk).
Some people don't mind the thought of surgery. Personally, it creeps me out, and I'm going to avoid it if at all possible.
Once upon a time I was scheduled for emergency surgery for my ruptured L5_S1 disc. That night I found two books that literally in two days allowed me to go from only being able to be on my feet for 10 minutes at a time to being on my feet all day long. Needless to say, I cancelled the next day's surgery.
The point is, even things that seem like they require surgery, don't necessarily.
Surgery for carpal tunnel or tennis elbow or wrist tendonitis, etc, may seem like minor surgeries, but they're still surgery, and even if everything goes perfect, there's no guarantee it's going to make anything better.
And you still have to recover from the surgery itself, even if everything goes perfect.
Remember, even if you feel better after surgery, surgery does NOT reduce any of the factors that caused the problem in the first case.
Yes, there are people that get great results from surgery. Everybody and every situation and every doctor is different.
You pay your money and take your chances. There's no money back guarantee.
If you're saying "But I've tried every Tendonitis treatment there is," you might want to look around a little more and try something else. You definitely haven't tried everything.
You'll find the RIGHT tool for the job sooner or later.
Return to the top of this Tendonitis Surgery page.
Go to the main Tendonitis page.
Go to the www.TendonitisExpert.com homepage.
|Share Your Story